The Fifth Child by Doris Lessing

“You two are incorrigible,” said William. “They are hopeless,” he said to the others. “Well, who’s complaining? I’m not! Why don’t we all go for that picnic?”

  The house party filled five cars, children wedged in or on the adults’ laps.

  Summer was the same: two months of it, and again the family came and went, and came again. The schoolgirl was there all the time, poor Bridget, clinging fast to this miracle of a family. Rather, in fact, as Harriet and David did. Both more than once—seeing the girl’s face, reverential, even awed, always on the watch as if she feared to miss some revelation of goodness or grace the moment she allowed her attention to lapse—saw themselves. Even uneasily saw themselves. It was too much … excessive.… Surely they should be saying to her, “Look here, Bridget, don’t expect so much. Life isn’t like that!” But life is like that, if you choose right: so why should they feel she couldn’t have what they had so plentifully?

  Even before the crowd gathered before the Christmas of 1973, Harriet was pregnant again. To her utter dismay, and David’s. How could it have happened? They had been careful, particularly so because of their determination not to have any more children for a while. David tried to joke, “It’s this room, I swear it’s a baby-maker!”

  They had put off telling Dorothy. She was not there, anyway, because Sarah had said it was unfair that Harriet got all the help. Harriet simply could not manage. One after another, three girls came to help; they had just left school and could not easily find work. They were not much good. Harriet believed she looked after them more than they her. They came or didn’t come as the mood took them, and would sit around drinking tea with their girl-friends while Harriet toiled. She was frantic, exhausted … she was peevish; she lost her temper; she burst into tears.… David saw her sitting at the kitchen table, head in her hands, muttering that this new foetus was poisoning her: Paul lay whimpering in his pram, ignored. David took a fort-night’s leave from his office to come home and help. They had known how much they owed Dorothy, but now knew it better—and that when she heard Harriet was pregnant again she would be angry. Very. And she would be right.

  “It will all be easier when Christmas starts,” wept Harriet.

  “You can’t be serious,” said David, furious. “Of course they can’t come this Christmas.”

  “But it is so easy when people are here, everyone helps me.”

  “Just for once we’ll go to one of them,” said David, but this idea did not live for more than five minutes: none of the other households could accommodate six extra people.

  Harriet lay weeping on her bed. “But they must come, don’t put them off—oh, David, please … at least it’ll keep my mind off it.”

  He sat on his side of the bed watching her, uneasy, critical, trying not to be. Actually he would be pleased not to have the house full of people for three weeks, a month: it cost so much, and they were always short of money. He had taken on extra work, and here he was at home, a nursemaid.

  “You simply have to get someone in to help, Harriet. You must try and keep one of them.”

  She burst out in indignation at the criticism. “That’s not fair! You aren’t here stuck with them—they aren’t any good. I don’t believe any of these girls have done an hour’s work in their lives.”

  “They’ve been some help—even if it’s only the washing-up.”

  Dorothy telephoned to say that both Sarah and Harriet were going to have to manage: she, Dorothy, needed a break. She was going home to her flat to please herself for a few weeks. Harriet was weeping, hardly able to speak. Dorothy could not get out of her what could possibly be wrong: she said, “Very well, I suppose I’ll have to come, then.”

  She sat at the big table with David, Harriet, the four children there, too, and looked severely at Harriet. She had understood her daughter was pregnant again within half an hour of arriving. They could see from her set angry face that she had terrible things to say. “I’m your servant, I do the work of a servant in this house.” Or, “You are very selfish, both of you. You are irresponsible.” These words were in the air but were not spoken: they knew that if she allowed herself to begin she would not stop with this.

  She sat at the head of the table—the position near the stove—stirring her tea, with one eye on baby Paul, who was fretful in his little chair and wanted to be cuddled. Dorothy, too, looked tired, and her grey hair was disordered: she had been going up to her room to tidy herself when she had been swallowed in embraces with Luke and Helen and Jane, who had missed her and knew that the crossness and impatience that had ruled the house would now be banished.

  “You know that everyone is expecting to come here for Christmas,” she demanded heavily, not looking at them.

  “Oh yes, yes, yes,” clamoured Luke and Helen, making a song and dance of it and rushing around the kitchen. “Oh yes, when are they coming? Is Tony coming? Is Robin coming? Is Anne coming?”

  “Sit down,” said David, sharp and cold, and they gave him astonished, hurt looks and sat.

  “It’s crazy,” said Dorothy. She was flushed with the hot tea and with all the things she was forcing herself not to say.

  “Of course everyone has to come,” Harriet said, weeping—and ran out of the room.

  “It’s very important to her,” said David apologetically.

  “And not to you?” This was sarcastic.

  “The thing is, I don’t think Harriet is anywhere near herself,” said David, and held his eyes on Dorothy’s, to make her face him. But she would not.

  “What does that mean, my mother isn’t near herself?” enquired Luke, the six-year-old, ready to make a word game of it. Even, perhaps, a riddle. But he was perturbed. David put out his arm and Luke went to his father, stood close, looked up into his face.

  “It’s all right, Luke,” said David.

  “You’ve got to get someone in to help,” said Dorothy.

  “We have tried.” David explained what had happened with the three amiable and indifferent girls.

  “Doesn’t surprise me. Who wants to do an honest job these days?” said Dorothy. “But you have to get someone. And I can tell you I didn’t expect to end my days as your and Sarah’s skivvy.”

  Here Luke and Helen gave their grandmother incredulous looks and burst into tears. After a pause, Dorothy controlled herself and began consoling them.

  “All right, it’s all right,” she said. “And now I’m going to put Paul and Jane to bed. You two, Luke and Helen, can put yourselves to bed. I’ll come up and say good night. And then your gran is off to bed. I’m tired.”

  The subdued children went off upstairs.

  Harriet did not come down again that evening; her husband and her mother knew she was being sick. Which they were used to … but were not used to ill temper, tears, fretfulness.

  When the children were in bed, David did some of the work he had brought home, made himself a sandwich, and was joined by Dorothy, who had come down to make herself tea. This time they did not exchange irritabilities: they were together in a companionable silence, like two old campaigners facing trials and difficulties.

  Then David went up into the great shadowy bedroom, where lights from an upstairs window in a neighbouring house a good thirty yards away sent gleams and shadows on to the ceiling. He stood looking at the big bed where Harriet lay. Asleep? Baby Paul was lying asleep close to her, unwrapped. David cautiously leaned over, folded Paul into his cuddling blanket, took him to his room next door. He saw Harriet’s eyes shine as she followed his movements.

  He got into bed and, as always, slid out his arm so that she could put her head on to it and be gathered close to him.

  But she said, “Feel this,” and guided his hand to her stomach.

  She was nearly three months pregnant.

  This new baby had not yet shown signs of independent life, but now David felt a jolt under his hand, quite a hard movement.

  “Can you be further along than you thought?” Once more he felt the thrust, and could not believ
e it.

  Harriet was weeping again, and he felt, knowing of course this was unfair, that she was breaking the rules of some contract between them: tears and misery had not ever been on their agenda!

  She felt rejected by him. They had always loved to lie here feeling a new life, greeting it. She had waited four times for the first little flutters, easily mistaken but then certain; the sensation that was as if a fish mouthed out a bubble; the small responses to her movements, her touch, and even—she was convinced—her thoughts.

  This morning, lying in the dark before the children woke, she had felt a tapping in her belly, demanding attention. Disbelieving, she had half sat up, looking down at her still flat, if soft, stomach, and felt the imperative beat, like a small drum. She had been keeping herself on the move all day, so as not to feel these demands from the new being, unlike anything she had known before.

  “You had better go and get Dr. Brett to check the dates,” said David.

  Harriet said nothing, feeling it was beside the point: she did not know why she felt this.

  But she did go to Dr. Brett.

  He said, “Well, perhaps I was out by a month—but if so, you have really been very careless, Harriet.”

  This scolding was what she was getting from everyone, and she flashed out, “Anyone can make a mistake.”

  He frowned as he felt the emphatic movements in her stomach, and remarked, “Well, there’s nothing very much wrong with that, is there?” He looked dubious, however. He was a harassed, no longer young man, who, she had heard, had a difficult marriage. She had always felt rather superior to him. Now she felt at his mercy, and was looking up into that professionally reticent face as she lay there, under his hands, longing for him to say something else. What? An explanation.

  “You’ll have to take it easy,” he said, turning away.

  Behind his back, she muttered, “Take it easy yourself!” and chided herself, You bad-tempered cow.

  Everyone arriving for Christmas was told Harriet was pregnant—it was a mistake—but now they were pleased, really.… But “Speak for yourselves,” said Dorothy. People had to rally around, even more than they always did. Harriet was not to cook, do housework, do anything. She must be waited upon.

  Each new person looked startled on hearing this news, then made jokes. Harriet and David came into rooms full of family, talking, who fell silent knowing they were there. They had been exchanging condemnations. Dorothy’s role in keeping this household going was being given full credit. The pressure on David’s salary—not, after all, a large one—was mentioned. Jokes were made about James’s probable reception of the news. Then the teasing began. David and Harriet were commended for their fertility, and jokes were made about the influences of their bedroom. They responded to the jokes with relief. But all this jesting had an edge on it, and people were looking at the young Lovatts differently from the way they had done before. The quietly insistent patient quality that had brought them together, that had caused this house to come into being and had summoned all these unlikely people from various parts of England, and the world, too—James was coming from Bermuda, Deborah from the States, and even Jessica had promised to put in a brief appearance—this quality, whatever it was, this demand on life, which had been met in the past with respect (grudging or generous), was now showing its reverse side, in Harriet lying pale and unsociable on her bed, and then coming down determined to be one of the party but failing, and going upstairs again; in Dorothy’s grim patience, for she worked from dawn to dusk and often in the night, too; and in the children’s querulousness and demands for attention—particularly little Paul’s.

  Another girl came in from the village, found by Dr. Brett. She was, like the other three, pleasant, lazy, seeing nothing to be done unless her attention was directed to it, affronted by the amount of work needed by four children. She did, however, enjoy the people sitting around and talking, the sociable atmosphere, and in no time she was sharing meals and sitting around with them; she found it quite in order to be waited on by them. Everyone knew that she would find an excuse to leave when this delightful house party broke up.

  Which it did, rather earlier than usual. It was not only Jessica (in her bright summer clothes that made no concession to the English winter except for a slight cardigan) who remembered people elsewhere who had been promised visits. Jessica took herself off, and Deborah with her. James followed. Frederick had to finish a book. The enraptured schoolgirl, Bridget, found Harriet lying down, her hands pressed into her stomach, tears running down her face, moaning from some pain she would not specify—and was so shocked she, too, wept and said she had always known it was too good to last, and went off back home to her mother, who had just remarried and did not really want her.

  The girl who had come to help went home, and David looked for a trained nanny in London. He could not afford one, but James had said he would pay for it. Until Harriet was better, he said: uncharacteristically grumpy, he was making it clear he thought that Harriet had chosen this life and now should not expect everyone to foot the bill.

  But they could not find a nanny: the nannies all wanted to go abroad with families who had a baby, or perhaps two; or to be in London. This small town, and the four children, with another coming, put them off.

  Instead, Alice, a cousin of Frederick’s, a widow down on her luck, came to help Dorothy. Alice was quick, fussy, nervous, like a little grey terrier. She had three grown-up children, and grandchildren, but said she did not want to be a nuisance to them, a remark that caused Dorothy to make dry remarks, which Harriet felt like accusations. Dorothy was not pleased to have a woman of her own age sharing authority, but it could not be helped. Harriet seemed unable to do anything much.

  She went back to Dr. Brett, for she could not sleep or rest because of the energy of the foetus, which seemed to be trying to tear its way out of her stomach.

  “Just look at that,” she said as her stomach heaved up, convulsed, subsided. “Five months.”

  He made the usual tests, and said, “It’s large for five months, but not abnormally so.”

  “Have you ever had a case like this before?” Harriet sounded sharp, peremptory, and the doctor gave her an annoyed look.

  “I’ve certainly seen energetic babies before,” he said shortly, and when she demanded, “At five months? Like this?” he refused to meet her—was dishonest, as she felt it. “I’ll give you a sedative,” he said. For her. But she thought of it as something to quiet the baby.

  Now, afraid of asking Dr. Brett, she begged tranquillisers from friends, and from her sisters. She did not tell David how many she was taking, and this was the first time she had hidden anything from him. The foetus was quiet for about an hour after she dosed herself, and she was given a respite from the ceaseless battering and striving. It was so bad that she would cry out in pain. At night, David heard her moan, or whimper, but now he did not offer comfort, for it seemed that these days she did not find his arms around her any help.

  “My God,” she said, or grunted, or groaned, and then suddenly sat up, or scrambled out of bed and went doubled up out of the room, fast, escaping from the pain.

  He had stopped putting his hand on her stomach, in the old companionable way, for what he felt there was beyond what he could manage with. It was not possible that such a tiny creature could be showing such fearful strength; and yet it did. And nothing he said seemed to reach Harriet, who, he felt, was possessed, had gone right away from him, in this battle with the foetus, which he could not share.

  He might wake to watch her pacing the room in the dark, hour after hour. When she at last lay down, regulating her breathing, she would start up again, with an exclamation, and, knowing he was awake, would go downstairs to the big family room where she could stride up and down, groaning, swearing, weeping, without being observed.

  As the Easter holiday approached and the two older women made remarks about getting the house ready, Harriet said, “They can’t come. They can’t possibly come.”


  “They’ll expect it,” said Dorothy.

  “We can manage,” said Alice.

  “No,” said Harriet.

  Wails and protests from the children, and Harriet did not soften. This made Dorothy even more disapproving. Here she was, with Alice, two capable women, doing all the work, and the least Harriet could do …

  “You’re sure you don’t want them to come?” asked David, who had been begged by the children to make her change her mind.

  “Oh, do what you like,” Harriet said.

  But when Easter came, Harriet was proved right: it was not a success. Her strained, abstracted face as she sat there at her table, stiffly upright, braced for the next jolt, or jab, stopped conversation, spoiled the fun, the good times. “What have you got in there?” asked William, jocular but uneasy, seeing Harriet’s stomach convulse. “A wrestler?”

  “God only knows,” said Harriet, and she was bitter, not joking. “How am I going to get through to July?” she demanded, in a low appalled voice. “I can’t! I simply can’t do it!”

  They all—David, too—judged that she was simply exhausted because this baby was coming too soon. She must be humoured. Alone in her ordeal—and she had to be, she knew that, and did not blame her family for not accepting what she was being slowly forced to accept—she became silent, morose, suspicious of them all and their thoughts about her. The only thing that helped was to keep moving.

  If a dose of some sedative kept the enemy—so she now thought of this savage thing inside her—quiet for an hour, then she made the most of the time, and slept, grabbing sleep to her, holding it, drinking it, before she leaped out of bed as it woke with a heave and a stretch that made her feel sick. She would clean the kitchen, the living-room, the stairs, wash windows, scrub cupboards, her whole body energetically denying the pain. She insisted that her mother and Alice let her work, and when they said there was no need to scrub the kitchen again, she said, “For the kitchen no, for me yes.” By breakfast time she might have already worked for three or four hours, and looked hagridden. She took David to the station, and the two older children to school, then parked the car somewhere and walked. She almost ran through streets she hardly saw, hour after hour, until she understood she was causing comment. Then she took to driving a short way out of the town, where she walked along the country lanes, fast, sometimes running. People in passing cars would turn, amazed, to see this hurrying driven woman, white-faced, hair flying, open-mouthed, panting, arms clenched across her front. If they stopped to offer help, she shook her head and ran on.